# Camera presentability plan

Goal: IdleSpectator never starts **Watching** on a beat the orange dossier would blank or refuse.
Ambient object-falls stop competing with real story (combat, birth, plot, kingdom) without chasing per-asset denylists.

This plan follows live Player.log audits after event-live verification (Phases 0–5 done).
Coverage of *firing* is largely solved.
Idle *quality* fails on ranking / ownership mismatch, not missing catalogs.

## Problem (from live idle)

| Symptom | Root |
|---------|------|
| ~60% watches are vegetation / object falls | Building destroy feed registers A at high strength |
| Tip → `identity_filter` → `max_cap` loop | Selection ≠ presentation: `"A Maple Tree falls near X"` fails dossier identity rules |
| Combat sticky via `below_margin` while falls cut in | Falls outrank or interrupt poorly; sticky fights do not lose focus cleanly |
| `no_focus_while_idle` BAD after `max_cap` / `follow_lost` / `quiet_grace` | Focus hold across scene end is broken |
| Tip `"Watching: something interesting"` | Empty Label placeholder in `CameraDirector.FormatWatchTip` |

## Principles (do not violate)

1. **Selection equals presentation.**
   If `UnitDossier.EventLabelBeat` / scene identity rules would empty the reason for the follow subject, that candidate must not win Watching.
2. **Policy overlays classes, not asset ids.**
   Demote "ambient building/object fall" as a feed family or WorldLog shape predicate.
   Do not maintain Maple / Poop / Mineral id lists.
3. **Game remains source of truth for inventory.**
   Authored dials set strength / CreatesInterest / watch windows.
   They do not invent which buildings exist.
4. **Layer B stays honest.**
   Falls may still hit Activity / Life when useful.
   Demotion means "not camera A," not "erase from the world."
5. **One invariant over many patches.**
   Prefer a shared presentability gate at register / rank time over scattered feed hacks.

## Architecture target

```
observe → confirm → emit Label
                ↓
         presentability gate  (same rules as UnitDossier)
                ↓
         CreatesInterest / strength policy (class overlay)
                ↓
         InterestDirector rank → Watching
                ↓
         dossier shows the same Label (or scene ends)
```

Drop reason for the new gate: `unpresentable` (or reuse `identity_filter` with a clear prefix) in `InterestDropLog`.

## Phase A - Presentability gate (structural, do first)

**Invariant:** unpresentable beats never become the active EventLed scene.

### A1. Shared check

Extract a single helper used by both dossier and director, e.g. `EventPresentability.WouldShow(Actor subject, string label)` (or static on `UnitDossier`).

It must mirror:

- identity / weak flavor rejection
- `LeadsWithForeignName` / stranger scrub for the follow subject
- empty / placeholder Labels

Do **not** fork a second, looser copy of the rules.

### A2. Gate at publish or rank

Preferred order:

1. Soft reject in `EventFeedUtil.Register` when Label fails for `follow` (record drop, return null) - catches most unit-led noise early.
2. Hard reject in `InterestDirector` before adopting a candidate (defense in depth for location-only / race cases).

Location-only falls without a subject: either fail presentability by policy, or never register as A (Phase B).

### A3. Harness

Add focused asserts (new scenario or nest in existing director smoke):

| Case | Expect |
|------|--------|
| Register Label that dossier blanks for follow | no Watching; drop logged |
| Register subject-led presentable Label | Watching + orange reason match Label |
| Inject / live path that previously `identity_filter` after cut | no cut-in |

Exit: idle session no longer shows Watching → immediate `identity_filter` on the same tip as the dominant pattern.

Gate: `critical_smoke` + a dedicated presentability scenario ×3.

## Phase B - Demote ambient fall class (policy overlay)

**Class:** unit-adjacent or location-only **building/object destroy** ambient (trees, plants, minerals, mushrooms, poop, etc.).

Not in scope for demotion: intentional spectacle consumes (`building_consume` / eat when an actor is clearly the subject and Label is subject-led), war siege set-pieces if we later mark them Signal.

### B1. Predicate, not id list

In `BuildingEventPatches.PostfixStartDestroy` (and any WorldLog twin if it feeds the same shape):

- Default destroy → Layer B only (`CreatesInterest=false` / skip `EventFeedUtil.Register`, still Activity if desired).
- Or register A only when a **strong subject-led** story exists (actor is clearly damaging/consuming, not "nearest unit to a falling bush").

Nearest-unit attach for ambient falls is the bug pattern.
Prefer: no follow invent from proximity for A.

### B2. Catalog dials

If WorldLog building-destroy ids are camera today, set class default `camera: false` / low strength via discovery overlay rules - still not per maple id.

Update `docs/event-audit.md` Layer A noise notes when done.

### B3. Harness

| Case | Expect |
|------|--------|
| Destroy ambient vegetation near a unit | no A cut; optional B log |
| `BehConsumeTargetBuilding` with living eater | still A, subject-led Label |
| Building destroy pipeline in `event_live_pipelines` | `id_drop` or B-only as authored; not FAIL |

Exit: live idle fall watch share collapses; combat/birth/plot reclaim camera time.

## Phase C - Ban empty Watching tip

### C1. Product rule

Never show `Watching: something interesting`.

Options (pick one, keep simple):

- Refuse to start Watching without a non-empty presentable Label.
- Or tip omits reason / uses task chip only when Label empty (Character fill already uses empty Label intentionally - do not use FormatWatchTip placeholder there).

Remove or guard the fallback in `CameraDirector.FormatWatchTip`.

### C2. Harness

Assert tip never equals / contains the placeholder string during idle EventLed scenes.

## Phase D - Focus hold across scene end

Separate from fall demotion; required for idle quality.

### D1. Reproduce

`no_focus_while_idle` after `max_cap`, `follow_lost`, `quiet_grace`.
Reproduce closest to end-user idle (spectate, wait for scene churn) before patching.

### D2. Fix

When an EventLed scene ends and Character fill / next candidate should continue idle:

- Keep or immediately reacquire a living focus unit.
- Do not clear follow in a way that flashes the power bar or trips BAD.
- Every director tick: if Idle is on and camera has no living focus, reattach current follow/related or `EnsureIdleFocus` (do not wait for quiet_grace).

Document intended end-of-scene focus ownership in `event-audit.md` interrupt/hold section.

### D3. Harness

Assert: during SpectatorMode, after forced `max_cap` / quiet_grace end, `MoveCamera.hasFocusUnit()` remains true (or is restored within one director tick) unless world has no living units.

## Phase E - Optional Label rework (only if we want some falls as A)

Only after A+B.

Rewrite `EventReason.BuildingFalls` to subject-led form if product wants rare A falls:

- Bad: `A Maple Tree falls near Boh` (foreign-led / identity_filter)
- Better: `Boh is near a falling maple tree` (only if Phase B still allows that class as A)

Do not use Label rewrite as a substitute for the gate or class demotion.

## Phase F - Docs + idle quality gate

1. Cross-link from `event-reason.md` and `event-audit.md`.
2. Add a short "idle quality" checklist to `event-e2e.md`:
   - no Watching → identity_filter churn on same tip
   - no placeholder tip
   - no `no_focus_while_idle` BAD spike in a quiet idle window
   - fall class not dominating watches
3. Player.log soak auditor: `./scripts/soak-audit-player-log.sh [seconds]` (also `--since-bytes N`).

## Implementation status

| Phase | Status |
|-------|--------|
| A Presentability gate | Done - `EventPresentability` + Register/SelectNext/SwitchTo; harness bypass for synthetic tips |
| B Fall class demotion | Done - `Building.startDestroyBuilding` is B-only; consume stays A |
| C Placeholder tip ban | Done - `FormatWatchTip` returns `Watching` when Label empty |
| D Focus hold | Done - `MaintainCameraFocus` every tick; orphan scenes end without quiet_grace gap |
| E Label rewrite | Done early - `BuildingFalls` subject-led (for residual / Activity prose) |
| F Docs + idle quality gate | Done - `camera_presentability` in regression; docs synced |

## Order of work

| Order | Phase | Why first |
|------:|-------|-----------|
| 1 | A Presentability gate | Fixes whole contradiction class forever |
| 2 | B Fall class demotion | Stops ambient spam without id lists |
| 3 | C Placeholder tip ban | Cheap, visible polish; blocks empty A |
| 4 | D Focus hold | Fixes BAD / churn; independent root cause |
| 5 | E Label rewrite | Optional; only if some falls stay A |
| 6 | F Docs / soak gate | Locks the bar |

Do not start with per-id JSON demotions.
Do not demote only and skip the gate.

## Non-goals

- Hand-authored denylist of building asset ids
- Treating inject coverage as idle-quality proof
- Making every WorldLog message camera-worthy
- Solving spell / biome / boat unload unsupported fires in this plan
- Beh-positive `family_group_join` (separate observation work)

## Success criteria

- Presentability helper is the single source of truth for "would orange show this?"
- Ambient object-falls are B-by-default (class predicate)
- Zero Watching cuts whose tip is immediately identity-filtered
- Zero `"something interesting"` tips in EventLed Watching
- Idle soak: `no_focus_while_idle` BAD count stays near zero across scene churn
- Regression still green (`critical_smoke` ×3; `regression` after A–D)

## See also

- [event-reason.md](event-reason.md) - A/B layers, EventReason, dossier filters
- [event-audit.md](event-audit.md) - dials, interrupt / hold / grace
- [event-live-verification-plan.md](event-live-verification-plan.md) - fire accuracy (done)
- [event-e2e.md](event-e2e.md) - harness suite map
- [event-observation.md](event-observation.md) - observe → confirm → emit